Information

Dear forum members,
We are delighted to inform you that our forums are back online. Every single topic and post are now on their places and everything works just as before, only better. Welcome back!



Discussion

Discussion on Article:
The Fastest Graphics Cards of Summer 2004

Started by: lol | Date 08/01/04 08:24:29 PM
Comments: 80 | Last Comment:  12/09/16 10:47:12 AM

Expand all threads | Collapse all threads

[1-11]

1. 
Note to the author, regarding your IL-2:FB tests. This sim plays faster in OpenGL with better graphical quality and in that regime the nVidia cards equal and better their ATI counterparts easily. It is obvious from your numbers that you tested in Direct3D. Just thought you should know.
0 0 [Posted by:  | Date: 08/01/04 08:46:55 PM]
Reply
- collapse thread

 
In fact, we used OpenGL render-path for IL2.
0 0 [Posted by:  | Date: 08/03/04 02:43:30 PM]
Reply
 
Just to reiterate. I test FB all the time because it is my main pass-time. On my meager rig (P4 2.4C, 1GB PC3200 RAM and Radeon 9700, non-pro) I average 26fps on the highest possible settings (perfect landscape) in OpenGL, black-death track, at 1024x768x32 + 4xFSAA and no Aniso. Explain to me how I can get almost double the frame rates of the Radeon 9800XT at 1024x768 with my aging rig? Explain to me how every other FB player is getting comparable results to mine? I'm sorry but your numbers just don't jive.

If you are unaware, "The Black Death" track is the most widely used benchmarking utility in the FB world because of it's incredible load on both the CPU and the graphics card.
0 0 [Posted by:  | Date: 08/03/04 02:55:36 PM]
Reply
 
We did not use "The Black Death" track, which is why you should not compare your results to us, especially keeping in mind that we have totally different system compared to yours.
0 0 [Posted by:  | Date: 08/06/04 12:53:46 PM]
Reply
 
Look, I'm not a fan of either brand of video card and don't care who's on top. But this is an obviouse case of testing error. I don't care what track you're using there's something fishy with your results. As I said, they are lower than the numbers I'm getting on my low end rig on one of the most demanding demo tracks in FB.

I can't understand your arrogance? Everyone else has posted completely different numbers whether they be other online reviewers or other gamers using FB and yet you refuse to even entertain the idea that something is wrong with how you tested. Incredible! I'll leave you to your ATI-worship - at least I now know where you stand. B'Bye now...
0 0 [Posted by:  | Date: 08/08/04 11:17:28 PM]
Reply

2. 
First off, well done on doing such a large and exhaustive review that no doubt took a long time.

However, there is a flaw. Why must Xbitlabs ALWAYS neglect to mention that Nvidia's driver optimizations are turned OFF?

You cannot turn off ATI's optimizations, and so ATI gets the edge once you turn on AA+AF.

If you were to re-run the benches with Nvidia's optimizations ON, then Nvidia would have looked alot better with AA+AF..

Atleast edit your review and put the important information of whether Nvidia's optimizations are on or off in the test bed section..
0 0 [Posted by:  | Date: 08/02/04 08:00:36 PM]
Reply
- collapse thread

 
We enabled trilinear and anisotropic filtering optimizations for NVIDIA GeForce cards.
0 0 [Posted by:  | Date: 08/03/04 02:16:47 PM]
Reply
 
Which tests?
0 0 [Posted by:  | Date: 08/04/04 12:15:49 PM]
Reply

3. 
I'm impressed by the scope of the article. Very well done. We need articles like this. :)
Unfortunately though, this article was far too biased to be taken seriously.

Whenever NVidia wins, we get a comment like "NVIDIA’s solutions are evidently better in this game, but it’s hard to account for this fact." and "At least we can’t lay blame on the low geometry processing speed anymore – ATI’s new graphics processor is NVIDIA’s better in this respect as you know."
What we *know* is that NVidia won that benchmark. Trying to pass that off as some anomaly, while stating (without any proof) that ATI's cards are better in this respect, just doesn't sound very professional. If they are better, show us. If you can't show us, don't pretend that it's a fact.

Other comments are "With FSAA and AF enabled, NVIDIA’s graphics cards look unsure, as we’ve seen a number of times, since their algorithms of working with the memory are less efficient." about a benchmark where the 6800 U beats the X800XT with 10+ fps. If that is unsure, then what is ATI's cards? Paralyzed?

But when ATI cards are ahead, there's no need to look for an explanation.
In another, we're told that the 3-5 fps difference (in NVidia's favor) is a "small difference", but a few pages earlier, ATI is said to perform better because it has about the same number of fps over the NV cards.

"The RADEON X800 XT equals the GeForce 6800 Ultra in this game" about a benchmark where the 6800 Ultra wins with 8/1/4 fps (for each resolution)
We're talking about something like a 10% lead to NVidia here.

"The top-end members of the new GPU series from ATI and NVIDIA again give out the same number of frames per second" in Flight Simulator 2004, where the 6800 U wins by 3-4 fps in all resolutions and in pure as well as eye candy, but on the next page (X2), "The RADEON X800 XT seems to be winning in this test", despite only having a lead of 0.6, 1.5 and 0.6 fps in the different resolutions.
In Eye Candy, the 6800 U pulls ahead by 7, 3 and 1 fps, but we're told that "The situation hardly changes in the “eye candy” mode"

I'm not questioning the benchmarks, and I'm not saying ATI's cards sucks, I'm asking for a fair description of the benchmarks. I'm still trying to decide which card to buy, and reading biased articles like this doesn't help. I want the best card, not the one from the reviewers favorite company.
0 0 [Posted by:  | Date: 08/03/04 08:46:56 AM]
Reply

4. 
Anton you need to address the fact that Nvidia's driver optimizations were turned OFF! You;re the only review site I've ever seen in which ATI beat Nvidia in CoD, which is an OpenGL game!

The reason for that is because Nvidia's AF optimizations were disabled, which isn't fair.
0 0 [Posted by:  | Date: 08/03/04 07:46:49 PM]
Reply

5. 
Disregard that last comment by me please... I just read that you said you did enable driver optimizations..

However, I find that weird because the NV40 always beats ATI in CoD.. If you look at some of your past reviews, you can see this clearly...
0 0 [Posted by:  | Date: 08/03/04 07:48:58 PM]
Reply

6. 
One mistake in your Microsoft flight simulator 04' bench's, is that the last eye candy mode benchmark, shows the same benchs as the non eye-candy mode, if someone could fix that with the eye candy mode benchs, it would be helpful.
0 0 [Posted by:  | Date: 08/04/04 07:35:27 AM]
Reply

7. 
>>If silence, compactness, power-saving are notions that matter much to you, or if you’re a real hardware enthusiast, consider the RADEON X800 Pro. Modders should be interested in this product since it can be converted into a ******RADEON X800 XT Extreme Edition****** with a bit of skill and luck. In this case you’ll get a nice performance boost. ATI’s R420 chip yield is very high and some of fully operational dies go to produce 12-pipeline cards. This is the ground for the conversion, although you should approach the problem soberly and not risk it if you don’t feel confident as to the outcome. !!
0 0 [Posted by:  | Date: 08/04/04 08:38:49 AM]
Reply
- collapse thread

 
Errr, my whole message didn't go through? Anyway, I hope you mean platnium edition and not extreme edition.

0 0 [Posted by:  | Date: 08/04/04 08:39:59 AM]
Reply

8. 
I love xbitlabs, but there is no way you guys are getting 50-70 fps in farcry with a 9800 pro/128 and all settings at the highest on 1024x768. Similar remarks in regards to all your other results
0 0 [Posted by:  | Date: 08/04/04 04:21:02 PM]
Reply

9. 
your high end graphics results r pretty useless since the rest of the system is causing some sort of bottleneck
0 0 [Posted by:  | Date: 08/10/04 03:24:40 AM]
Reply

10. 
please languange in german!!!!

0 0 [Posted by:  | Date: 08/11/04 02:40:01 AM]
Reply

11. 
kate spade outlet online
abercrombie & fitch
piumini moncler replica
oakley sunglasses
Kevin Durant Shoes
prada tote
Prada bags
michael kors outlet
mk outlet
air jordan shoes
michael kors outlet
Ralph Lauren
ate spade handbags
michael kors australia
official prada site
prada purses
burberry canada
huarache nike
asics Australia
beats headphones
kate spade outlet
michael kors outlet
michael kors uk
change points uk
kate spade black friday
pandora rings
pandora uk
Lebron 13
Nike Hyperdunk Shoes
coach australia
moncler jacket
michael kors outlet
coach outlet
burberry outlets
michael kors outlet
coach diaper bag
cheap ray ban sunglasses
coach outlet
pandora.com
burberry scarf
abercrombie outlet us
michael kors outlet
oakley frogskins sunglasses
kate spade purses outlet
mlb shop
nfl jerseys
michael kors bags
ugg uk
nike australia
pandora uk
prada online
official prada site
ugg australia
michael kors outlet
Michael Kors Watches Online
ugg slippers
pandora rings
nike shoes
michael kors handbags
chanel tote bag
tiffany co
abercrombie paris
michael kors purses
prada handbags
sheepskin boots
mlb shop
balenciaga us
michael kors outlet
burberry outlet canada
pandora jewelry
ray ban clubmaster
abercrombie outlet
china factory sale
burberry outlet online
ray-ban sunglasses
nike shox shoes
kate spade bags outlet
coach online
michael kors outlet
abercrombie and fitch
moncler us
moncler outlet
timberland boots
Prada Shopper Tote
louboutin shoes
true religion uk
nike outlet
coach shoes
paul smith uk
huaraches
abercrombie us
michael kors outlet store
ray ban prescription sunglasses
yeezy boost 350
cheap basketball shoes
official michael kors
kate spade outlet
michael kors italy
bercrombie Nederland
longchamp outlet
michael kors outlet
michael kors outlet
prada bags on sale
moncler clothing
mlb.com
kate spade
pandora necklace
Chanel Outlet
michael kors
prada outlet
Burberry Outlet
Michael Kors Canada
burberry outlet online
ray ban aviator
coach australia
michael kors outlet
paul smith sale
michael kors handbags outlet
coach outlet
ray ban sunglasses
burberry outlet
ray ban wayfarer
Basketball shoes
yeezy boost 350
michael kors outlet online
air yeezy shoes
abercrombie and fitch
nike australia
pandora necklace charms
pandora charms
Pandora bracelet
prada glasses
michael kors bags
Coach outlet online
Nike Air Max
coach bag
Kobe 9 Shoes
Michael Kors Watches
true religion jeans
ugg boots
ray-ban sunglasses
michael kors outlet
michael kors outlet
longchamp bag
michael kors purses
asics shoes Australia
ugg boots outlet
Michael Kors Outlet
Official Ralph Lauren UK Online Store
prada bags
michael kors purses on sale
kate spade outlet
B Derbyshire
coach australia
kate spade UK
abercrombie outlet
asics kayano
jimmy choo australia
longchamps
mens sunglasses
abercrombie and fitch
Oakley Holbrook sunglasses
pandora bracelet
michael kors handbags
michael kors online
ugg boots sale
michael kors outlet bags
Free Run
yeezy boost 350 shoes
burberry outlet
sheepskin boots on sale
sac longchamp
hermes bag
michael kors tote
beats by dre
michael kors outlet online
prada outlet online
ralph lauren
coach online
michael kors handbags
kate spade outlet
ray ban eyeglasses
rayban aviator
true religion
timberland uk
nike outlet
abercrombie outlet
jordan shoes
kate spade outlet online
paul smith
china wholesale
nike huarache
sunglasses sm
michael kors jet set tote
coach handbags
burberry outlet
nike shoes
uggs outlet
nike jordan
ugg boots uk
prada sunglasses
coach outlet,coach factory
chanel tote
nike shoes
ugg uk
coach outlet
moncler jacket
coach factory outlet online
ugg boots
coach outlet
michael kors us
major league baseball
pandora australia
ralph lauren australia
Nike Lebron 12
nike store
coach sunglasses for women
moncler coats
michael kors black friday
pandora princess ring
nike air max
coach outlet
pandora charms
oakley frogskins
veronique billat
lebron james shoes
michael kors outlet
Abercrombie Fitch
mk handbags
prada us
oakley australia
CHanel Factory Outlet
michael kors outlet
prada official site
burberry outlet
pandora charms sale
michael kors purses outlet
canada goose jacket
burberry scarf
coach factory outlet
kate spade
flash sunglasses
kate spade outlet
prada outlet online
nike shoes australia
Burberry outlet online
Nike Hyperdunk 2015
Nike Lebron Shoes
ray ban glasses
huaraches shoes
polo outlet
Michael Kors Watches Outlet
Ralph Lauren Polo
michael kors outlet
Coach Sunglasses Outlet
pirate system
ups tracking
michael kors outlet
abercrombie fitch
Mizuno Shop
michael kors
prada bags
nike shox
moncler jacket mens
pandora uk
Longchamp Outlet
burberry purse
ray ban online
pandora australia
nike jordan shoes
michael kors outlet
michael kors wallet
burberry scarfs
kate spade bags
prada outlet online
Oakley Outlet
ugg australia
air jordan retro
mlb store
beats studio
pandora australia
pandora rings jewelry
prada handbags
ralph lauren uk
Nike Jordans
coach
pandora rings
pandora bracelets
oakley outlet
Ray Ban Outlet
kate spade outlet
kate spade black friday
kate spade
landing gear
burberry outlet
michael kors outlet
michael kors factory outlet
pandora charms uk
michael kors canada
Burberry Factory Outlet
sunglasses outlet
prada bags
coach outlet online
nike com
pandora australia
prada bag
chanel bag
asics gel kayano
michael kors outlet
michael kors outlet
chanel australia
ugg boots
pandora bracelet
moncler sale
Prada Outlet
Yeezy Boost 350
coach factory outlet
Hyperdunk 2016
coach factory outlet
top sunglasses
kate spade outlet
KD 8 shoes
nike lebron james
coach handbags
R.B Sunglasses
coach sunglasses
Jordan Retro
nike outlet
nfl shop
burberry
Adidas Yeezy Boost 350
air jordan shoes
ray ban polarized
hermes uk
Coach Outlet Store
coach outlet online
abercrombie outlet
kate spade
nike basketball shoes
canada goose sale online
prada tote bag
Polo Ralph Lauren
asics shoes
coach bags
burberry
Pandora Charm
Polo Ralph Lauren
pandora charms
michael kors
burberry outlet
michael kors outlet
Nike Air Jordan
coach outlet
prada outlet
kate spade purses
hermes purses
Michael Kors Outlet
asics gel
longchamp sac
Burberry online
coach usa
moncler uk
michael kors outlet
shoes online
michael kors
michael kors bags
canada goose outlet
Bed and Breakfast in chesterfield
Kate Spade Australia
Nike Kobe 9
pandora rings
Hermes Outlet
hermes birkin
hermes birkin price
prada handbags
landinggear
ray ban new wayfarer
sunglasses hut
cheap coach purse
nike huarache shoes
pandora rings sale
yeezy shoes
michael kors
burberry australia
michael kors outlet online
nike store
longchamp backpack
coach carter
Nike KD 8
ralph lauren
burberry online
Mizuno Shoes
Ralph Lauren Polo
michael kors tote
brand sunglasses
salomon hiking shoes
Hugo Boss Outlet
nike lebron shoes
Cheap Ray Ban
ralph lauren shirts
pandora rings
burberry australia
true religion uk
ray-ban sunglasses
nike air huarache
chanel
coach outlet online
pandora bracelet
coach purse
burberry outlet canada
burberry us
sunglasses hut
pandora necklaces
moncler down jackets
burberry online
balenciaga bag
michael kors totes
coach factory
Coach Outlet Online
Jordan retro
burberry outlet
nike jordan shoes
burberry outlet online
pandora charms
coach outlet
MCM Outlet
kate spade bags
michael kors australia
burberry outlet
coach outlet online
véronique Billat
pandora rings
nike id
wholesale
pandora jewelry
coach outlet
prada outlet
ray ban sunglasses
Billat
Nike Air Jordan
Chanel Tote Bag 2015
burberry scarf
ralph lauren uk
Yeezy 350
moncler outlet
Nike Jordan Shoes
coach factory outlet
salomon shoes
ray ban prescription glasses
Hugo Boss Store
moncler mens jackets
coach bags
kate spade handbags
coach purses
Kobe X Shoes
landing gears
Mizuno Running Shoes
Hugo Boss Online
ugg boots uk
Nike Free
Chanel bags Outlet
burberry online
Coach Outlet
michael kors outlet
Mizuno Shop Japan
michael kors outlet
hermes uk
coach outlet online
jordan retro shoes
abercrombie outlet
Mizuno Wave
Oakley Holbrook
clk benz
shoes sale
burberry outlet
tiffany co
mk bags
baseball jerseys
nike shoes
Prada Factory Outlet
adidas yeezy boost 350
abercrombie us
pandora ring
michael kors outlet
burberry outlet
ugg slippers
kate spade canada
moncler jacket
michael kors bags outlet
polo online
shoes online sale
yeezy shoes adidas
Canada Goose Outlet
louboutin shoes
balenciaga bags
nike jordan shoes
coach outlet store
burberry canada
cheap moncler jacket
polo outlet online
Whitton Lodge Chesterfield Derbyshire UK
pandora jewelry
canada goose jacket
MIZUNO Shop US
moncler outlet
coach outlet
nike free run
Ralph Lauren UK
coach outlet online
sheepskin boots for women
Jordan Retro Shoes
snow boots
abssice 360
oakley sunglasses
Longchamp Bags
oakley sunglasses
canada goose sale
me adc12.9
0 0 [Posted by: meadc4  | Date: 12/09/16 10:47:12 AM]
Reply

[1-11]

Back to the Article

Add your Comment