Discussion

Discussion on Article:
Dual-Core Turion in Action: Acer Aspire 9300 Notebook Series

Started by: MonkRX | Date 03/05/07 06:53:19 PM
Comments: 9 | Last Comment:  02/23/08 09:59:19 PM

Expand all threads | Collapse all threads

[1-7]

1. 
Page 6, Major typo:
"As we said in the Introduction, the Acer Aspire 9303WSMi is based on a dual-core AMD Turion 64 X2 TL52 processor with a clock rate of 1.60GHz. This CPU is built on the 90nm Taylor core with two independent L2 caches, 512MB each. In all these parameters the AMD processor is inferior to Intel’s Core Duo and Core 2 Duo that are manufactured on 65nm tech process and have up to 4096MB of shared L2 cache. Like the single-core Turin 64, the Turion 64 X2 supports PowerNow!"

Its Turion, not Turin. Its KB, not MB. Feel free to delete this comment if you fix the typo.
[Posted by: MonkRX  | Date: 03/05/07 06:53:19 PM]
+ expand thread (1 answer)

2. 
Quake 3 ??? what a bad joke...
stopped reading right there. Most of the review is inconsistent, superficial and unsuccessfully tries to balance out its own imbalances...
Just the small ones:
TL-52 is NOT a competitor to T2300 Yonah on performance, TL-56 is for that.
Why bother testing graphics when the second notebook has different one.
Also why touting som much GF6100 being the only SM3.0 IGP?
When was the last time SM3.0 games were actually playable on ANY IGP?
While I appreciate the effort, too many lines where copy-pasted from marketing material. I at least hope so. No sane reviewer would praise notebook chipset(while a decent one) on SM3.0 capability. Period.
[Posted by: mino  | Date: 03/05/07 07:41:43 PM]

3. 
It seems this review has been check through a computerized grammar and spell checker with out going through a human. Everybody knows that grammar and spell checkers creates typos. A human being have to check the document before posting it to the public or else get criticize of bad workmanship.

Acer or Benq constructs inferior products. They are so cheap that their products will break after a few days. The notebook computer that is reviewed does not look like it can handle day to day abuse.

The benchmark utilities that the reviewer used only provides unrealistic estimate benchmarks. This review is lousy. Probably it will do better as a news article instead as a review.
[Posted by: linuxnerd  | Date: 03/05/07 09:00:31 PM]

4. 
Just to correct mino, I dont know if he ever had TL-52, I have one and it is more than comparable to T2300. It is faster in almost all test includind SiSoft, Everest. Of course it is slower in Intel sponsored benchmarks like PCMark.

I agree that it makes no sense to compare laptops with different graphics cards in terms of CPU speed, but it is very useful for someone who wants to buy the notebook. If AMD solution has 2% lower results and it is $300 cheaper, I think it is much better than intel solution.

Also in article they say as bad thing "mirror like" display, and actually it is positive thing to have Crystal Bright thing, and all of them have such display.

I currently have ASUS, but I still think this ACER is best for the money...
[Posted by: BorgDrone  | Date: 03/06/07 12:56:43 AM]
+ expand thread (1 answer)

5. 
I'm in the market for a laptop that is affordable and will run some games. this article helped tremendously. I really appreciate the detail of every aspect of this laptop. I was pretty much sold on it before i read the article, but the article still helped!
[Posted by: Lizle  | Date: 03/24/07 10:39:01 AM]

6. 
ATTETION; Sales Manager. i hope you doing well with business. we would like to purchase computer assocries

1= Acer Ferrari Laptops ----------------------100psc
2=Acer Aspire Laptops========50psc


STKIZIT COMPUTER SHOP
PLOT 77 WILLIAM STREET
P.O BOX 71134 KAMPALA UGANDA EAST AFRICA
TELE.256-752-524261
FAX,256-41-544565
EMAIL-stkizitoprisch@yahoo.co.uk

so please send us the price list of them
i look forward to hear from you soon
Regards
Deo M.
[Posted by: deo mukasa  | Date: 10/07/07 09:12:12 AM]

7. 
i have the acer aspire 9300 and i was wondering if you have taken your keyboard off to see if there are any places to upgrade under it (have a diff lappy with a ram slot and pci slot under its keyboard) id take off mine but i havent figured out how without just prying it up and im not sure if it has tabbs or if ill end up breaking it
[Posted by: jesterod  | Date: 02/23/08 09:59:19 PM]

[1-7]

You must log in to add comments.

Forgot password? Registration

remember me