<%BANNER[top_768x90]%>
<%BANNER[left_160x600_1]%>
<%BANNER[banner_468x60_h]%>

Discussion

<%BANNER[fp_160x600_r_1]%>

Discussion on Article:
Consumers Need More Motives to Migrate to High-Definition Video – Analysts.

Started by: Alien | Date 09/25/07 05:50:41 AM
Comments: 10 | Last Comment:  09/27/07 05:35:06 AM

Expand all threads | Collapse all threads

[1-6]

1. 
* Consumers Need More Motives to Migrate to High-Definition Video *

like adult entertainment... else this technology gonna die....
[Posted by: Alien | Date: 09/25/07 05:50:41 AM]

2. 
Here's how to motivate people: Don't have a format war! At this rate, this will turn into "SACD vs. DVD-Audio Part 2: We Didn't Learn the Last Time"
[Posted by: lonechicken | Date: 09/25/07 07:35:24 AM]
+ expand thread (1 answer)

3. 
To motivate me to trade up there would need to be a single OPEN format, not 2 diffrent closed formats which assume you're a thief, can be remotly shut down, vendord need to pay a liscence fee to use, will degrade output to my system unless i 'upgrade' all my top-notch kit to heavily encryption encoumbered stuff. I'm not goint to throw away all my home-cinema kit which is very good stuff to comply with their draconen HDCP system...

They will never get me to use it untill its an open format that dosn't force so much crap on the end user and is gaurenteed to be around a long time.
[Posted by: crisp | Date: 09/25/07 10:05:29 AM]
+ expand thread (1 answer)

4. 
When will they realise that open standards are good for everyone, and closed can only be bad.. also this DRM bullsh*t is getting stupid, they are shooting them selfs in the foot and taking the coustomers down with them
[Posted by: Sam | Date: 09/25/07 10:09:50 AM]
+ expand thread (2 answers)

5. 
I am never going to get any HD movies because of the format war, DRM, and HDCP.


Some motives:
* Provide a movie or video that shows readable object on a HD content, but shows it blurry in the standard DVD. An episode in Futurama has such tactics, but I am not sure if it is true.
* only one HD storage medium that everybody including consumers can agree on
* ease consumer setup instead making it harder such as the HDCP protocol
* no root-kit history in order for the drive to work.
* open format
[Posted by: linuxnerd | Date: 09/26/07 11:07:03 PM]

6. 
A Toshiba HD-A2 was on sale recently for the incredible price of $200 so I took the plunge into HD DVD. After a couple of firmware updates the player works great but I can't recommend this technology to anyone.

The first problem is that even after 2 years there is a limited selection of disks and the price point is still too high where I live. I don't mind spending some money but the next problem is that most modern movies in this format have an aspect ratio of 2.35:1 whereas most modern TVs have a 16:9 aspect ratio which is 1.78:1. This results in ugly horizontal black bars on the top and bottom of the screen. I'd rather buy / rent the regular wide screen DVD and use my previous generation Panasonic DVD player. It has an excellent built in scaler so 2.35:1 movies look great when scaled to fully fit my 1.78:1 plasma screen.

The increased clarity and quality of HD DVD isn't worth it if only 75% of my screen is being used. In a couple of months, once the novelty wears off, I think I'll dump my new player on EBay.

If a life long geek like myself isn't blown away by the high def hype, then I know the average consumer isn't going to be impressed either. As more HD programming becomes available on cable TV, I think Blu-ray and HD DVD will both die. The small increase in picture quality isn't worth it for the majority of consumers.
[Posted by: Kevin G. | Date: 09/26/07 11:35:09 PM]

[1-6]

You must log in to add comments.

Forgot password? Registration

remember me