Discussion

Discussion on Article:
Gigabyte GA-P35-DS3L (rev. 1.0) Mainboard Review

Started by: OldDummy | Date 01/05/08 06:36:24 AM
Comments: 29 | Last Comment:  04/25/08 03:34:44 PM

Expand all threads | Collapse all threads

[1-17]

1. 
hmm The board worked as per it's design and then burnt up the 4 pin connector on Quad OC load.

That to me is a design flaw. And should be able to be repeated......
[Posted by: OldDummy  | Date: 01/05/08 06:36:24 AM]
+ expand thread (2 answers)

2. 
Heh, I have order this board 2 days ago, now read the review. I am pleased with most of it, but the latest info scared me, I am buying this mobo for some serious OC and now i will have to check the temperatures of the power cable...man :-)
[Posted by: Jhc  | Date: 01/06/08 01:47:20 PM]
+ expand thread (1 answer)

3. 
Oh the fate.
I built a new box with this board November with E6750 and 8800GT.
It's been running awesome since day one. Never a hiccup. CPU easy clocked to 3.2Ghz. Zalman coolers on CPU/VGA as well.
Then all of a sudden just a couple days ago it went dead. I wasn't even doing anything, walked up to launch Firefox and got a BSOD. Could'nt read it before it rebooted. Now it just constantly reboots with no POST or anything. I heard 2 beeps once, but never again.
I've tried damn near everything and suspect the BIOS is corrupted somehow. So much for Durable.
I've been googling and reading for 2 days for answers and so far nothing. Sucks to be me.
[Posted by: Vader  | Date: 01/08/08 07:55:55 AM]
+ expand thread (2 answers)

4. 
The Empire Strikes Back

My continued weirdness with these new dang BIOS's that decide to start testing things before VGA is even on.
I, being the evil impatient type, went to a store and picked up a Rev2 DS3L to install last night.

Note to X-Bit, there is actually quite a bit of difference between the 2 boards on a small component level, in addition to the +2USB. When you hold them side by side it's easily seen. Whether it really makes a difference, who knows? Back to my story.

A flurry of tools and the new borad was installed and I was ready for more fate. Sure enough I was distraught with the following sequence.
No Beep/Post/Video, Fast Reboot
No Beep/Post/Video, Fast Reboot
No Beep/Post/Video, Fast Reboot
2 Beeps, No Post/Video, Fast Reboot
1 Beep, No Post/Video, Stays On.

I then went outside and cursed the sky.
A further 3 Post-It notes of trying different configurations and still no luck. Guess I can cancel my RMA. There is something else on the hose here.

Whoever decided to do this with BIOS/POST procedures should be shot, hung, quartered, and electrocuted by the Emperor himself.

I'll be going back to the store today to buy more pieces and my saga continues.

Ugh...
[Posted by: Vader  | Date: 01/10/08 05:41:40 AM]
+ expand thread (2 answers)

5. 
Does anyone know if this would be compatible with the brand spancking new Intel Core 2 Duo E8400 or E8500? Thats what im looking at getting but want to know compatability?
[Posted by: New Intel CPU Compatibility  | Date: 01/11/08 08:22:17 PM]
+ expand thread (1 answer)

6. 
I have now changed everything except the CPU and the house I live in. Absolutely disgusting.

Luckily my MicroCenter is out of E6750 so I have a chance at the new Wolfdale C2D which appear to be shipping next week 1/21 to 1/25 depending on vendor.

I have put a question to my Giagbyte contact on motherboard support for these chips. I'll let you know if I get answer.
[Posted by: Vader  | Date: 01/14/08 12:43:37 PM]
+ expand thread (2 answers)

7. 
Reply from Giga about C2D Wolfdale Support

"we need to wait until Intel officially release new cpu to check if current bios can support it to design new bios , will post on web for download when it is ready "

PooPoo ..
[Posted by: Vader  | Date: 01/14/08 04:56:20 PM]

8. 
The review says "and mainboards with the P index and two PCI Express x16 slots also have an 8-pin ATX12V connector."

But looking at the images at GB website, DS3P does seem to have a 4-pin ATX connector, instead of 8-pin?

The only image where I see 8-pin ATX is in DQ6 rev 1.1.

Am I correct?
[Posted by: Review is wrong?  | Date: 01/15/08 09:11:09 AM]

9. 
FWIW and FYI
Gigabyte as posted a Beta BIOS for upcoming E8X00 Wolfdales on DS3L Rev1 and Rev2 motherboards.
http://www.giga-byte.com/Support/Motherboard/BIOS_Model.a spx?ProductID=2629

Version F8a 2007/12/06

1. Beta Bios
2. Support Intel 45nm Wolfdale E8xxx series CPU

[Posted by: Vader  | Date: 01/15/08 10:06:42 AM]

10. 
Xbit is my one of my Favorite Sites.

Despite That,
After an incodent like that,
The article is Very Forgiving towards
Gigabyte Mb Frying the connector.

Any Long time system Builder will tell you that Gigabyte have always had the strangest quirks in their stripped down versions,and as you know,
usually their top line versions were never without flaws as well,despite the top dollars paid for it.

This forgiving attitude is by Other hardware sites is the Norm nowadays,
which keeps us from getting quality products.

But a Forgiving attitude from XBit,
is not acceptable.

Al ,an XbitLabs Fan
[Posted by: Al - System builder  | Date: 01/16/08 03:37:56 AM]

11. 
GSUSHCHRIST!! FINALLY!!

Comrades I have finally fixed my system.

To make a long story short.
My 2nd DS3L (Rev2) also did not work right out of the box, and had the same symptoms. After getting a new CPU from Intel, I could only conclude that this 2nd motherboard was also defunct and that my orginial Rev1 board had the same problem.

So I took the 2nd board back to Microcenter and exchanged it for an ASUS P5K. Install my wares and 1st boot was like a ray of light from the gods. Thank Odin for ASUS.

Gigabyte, you can blow me. Never again.
[Posted by: Vader  | Date: 01/23/08 07:03:42 PM]

12. 
I've tried the GA N650SLI DS4 and the GA P35 DS3L. Both are good boards for their price. The NB on the 650 got exceedingly hot and needed a fan for supplemental cooling.

Interestingly it is the SB on the P35 that's getting hot to the touch while the NB on my board at least is staying only warm, not "hot" - well, not too hot to touch anyway.

The mounting position of the SB heatsink vis the PCI-e video card will make it hard to mount an upgraded HSF on the SB.

I would have preferred NO Floppy Drive connection and two IDE connections instead. Failing that, why not mount the IDE connector where the Floppy is and relegate the Floppy connector to the bottom of the drive.

An "ON" light on the motherboard would be a very useful feature and would cost little to add.

I overclocked a E4300 to 3.45Ghz on the N650. It refused to go over 385FSB with a 9x multi and would not overclock above 250FSB with a 6x multi. 400FSB was out of the question no matter what the multi.

Currently overclocking a P4 3.4Ghz "650" processor on the GA P35 DS3L. It's gone to 4.55GHZ which may be the top or close to it.

Overall impression is that the boards perform fairly comparably although the GA P35 is slightly more stable and goes slightly higher while overclocking.

The bios routines on the two boards are similar, but with noticeable differences in the Advanced Overclocking section - particulary with respect to the memory settings.

The multi straps on the P35 DS3L are a major bonus that tip the scales definitely in its favor, in my opinion.
[Posted by: GA Newbie  | Date: 02/01/08 05:11:48 PM]
+ expand thread (2 answers)

13. 
I really appreciate the author's experience comments about the cooling and physical layouts.

There are readers out here that are not into overclocking, but do appreciate a fast and stable platform. Thanks for including the nominal performance results and pointing out the warts.
[Posted by: bgavin  | Date: 02/11/08 12:11:42 PM]

14. 
2x 4mmp Cu conductors soldered on the place of conector(ground and 12V)
[Posted by: me  | Date: 02/16/08 10:44:17 AM]

15. 
this is a great article
i currently own a ds3l

the only flaw i found so far is the NB heatsink
[Posted by: ry  | Date: 02/19/08 02:14:14 PM]

16. 
First-rate review, thanks!

I build business machines for clients and this review answered a lot of questions about suitability for business desktop use.

Other than the JMicron IDE controller, this board looks perfect for business users and others wanting maximum stability.

Thanks for pointing out the heat issue with the NB.
[Posted by: bgavin  | Date: 04/10/08 05:03:10 PM]

17. 
Very well
[Posted by: Honny  | Date: 04/25/08 03:34:44 PM]

[1-17]

You must log in to add comments.

Forgot password? Registration

remember me