Information

Dear forum members,
We are delighted to inform you that our forums are back online. Every single topic and post are now on their places and everything works just as before, only better. Welcome back!



Discussion

Discussion on Article:
The Battle of Low-Power Processors: Best Choice for a Nettop

Started by: CSMR | Date 09/25/08 10:58:35 PM
Comments: 55 | Last Comment:  01/04/17 10:27:51 AM

Expand all threads | Collapse all threads

[1-9]

1. 
Awful choice of system!
The article is called "low power processors: best choice for a nettop" but then you build high-power, low-performance systems! "A raptor, just the thing for my nettop"!
A low power system based on atom processors should consume about 15W idle, 25W load:
http://www.silentpcreview.com/article867-page5.html
And here is a system that is hugely more powerful than yours and lower-power at the same time (look at E7200 figures):
http://www.silentpcreview.com/article869-page5.html
0 0 [Posted by: CSMR  | Date: 09/25/08 10:58:35 PM]
Reply
- collapse thread

 
ASUS Eee Box uses Atom N-series processor and 945GSE chipset. That is why it has very low power consumption against tested systems based on Atom 230/330.

Let's compare:
Atom N270 (Eee) - 2.5W TDP
Atom 230 (Intel board) - 4W TDP
945GSE (Eee) - 6W TDP
945GC (Intel board) - 22W TDP

ASUS used the netbook platform in Eee, not nettop. And it is really low power as a result. But Intel doesn't sell netbook platform for end users at DIY market and you cannot build Eee-like system. Tested Intel and VIA nettop platforms have minimum power consumption among available choices.
0 0 [Posted by: Gavric  | Date: 09/26/08 04:39:03 AM]
Reply
 
OK, but the system has higher power consumption than much more powerful systems you can build on either the AMD or the Intel platform. For comparison among tested systems, there is some use, but you're not showing what the atom can do when you build a system that takes up as much power as a mainstream desktop.
0 0 [Posted by: CSMR  | Date: 09/26/08 06:04:46 AM]
Reply
 
Thank you for your feedback. This review does not show absolute minimum power consumption of the nettop systems. I had a different idea in mind. And I just compared some systems based on Atom and Nano face to face. These results help to choose a suitable platform for your needs. Building the lowest power system is a different story. In this case I could use "green" 5400RPM HDD, more efficient PSU etc.
0 0 [Posted by: Gavric  | Date: 09/26/08 06:37:14 AM]
Reply

2. 
Hi,

what kind of power supply were you using for the test ?
That could be very important, too.

thx

Bingle
0 0 [Posted by: Bingle  | Date: 09/26/08 02:33:27 AM]
Reply
- collapse thread

 
We have used Enermax ELT620AWT Liberty 620W power supply
0 0 [Posted by: Gavric  | Date: 09/26/08 04:58:54 AM]
Reply
 
Thx for the answer
0 0 [Posted by: Bingle  | Date: 09/26/08 04:21:02 PM]
Reply
 
That powerful power supply might make power consumption results a little skewed or off. You may want to look into anandtech's article on debunking power supply myths.
0 0 [Posted by: jmurbank  | Date: 09/26/08 04:35:18 PM]
Reply
 
This is terrible PSU setup given Atom system eats only 15W. Try a 50-65W PSU. You will understand what I am talking.
0 0 [Posted by: Roy2001  | Date: 10/02/08 10:57:07 AM]
Reply

3. 
There is no AMD systems. Combining Jetway JNC62K, AMD Athlon 64 X2 4850e, and a 2.5 inch hard drive will probably use less than 100 watts. Sure it will consume more power than those setups that you tested, but it will be more powerful and more useful in the graphics area. It can also be used in Linux with out any sacrifice of features.
0 0 [Posted by: jmurbank  | Date: 09/26/08 04:52:29 PM]
Reply

4. 
Good review, however comparing against a low clock celeron M such as the ones used in the original EEE would've been helpful, ie 630mhz or 900mhz celeron m.
0 0 [Posted by: blzd  | Date: 09/26/08 05:28:25 PM]
Reply
- collapse thread

 
I will write separate review to compare Celeron-based and Atom-based netbooks (Eees).
0 0 [Posted by: Gavric  | Date: 09/26/08 05:35:39 PM]
Reply

5. 
Where is Athlon 2000 with 8W TDP ?
0 0 [Posted by: mariusmotea  | Date: 09/27/08 02:32:16 AM]
Reply
- collapse thread

 
AMD low power Athlon 64 2000+ is not a nettop processor. It is embedded part. What is the difference? It's a price point. Total cost of AMD-based low power system in Mini-ITX form-factor will be around $300. But Intel and VIA based nettop platforms are provided in sub-$100 price range.
0 0 [Posted by: Gavric  | Date: 09/27/08 01:42:16 PM]
Reply

6. 
Hi,

are you working together with a Chinese site ?
If not, they copied your article:

http://en.hardspell.com/d...s_id=4155&pageid=3394

Better use watermarks in all your pictures next time ..

cheers

Bingle

P.S: Maybe I should ask about the used power supply there, too ^^
0 0 [Posted by: Bingle  | Date: 09/28/08 08:36:29 AM]
Reply
- collapse thread

 
They've stolen my review, really!
0 0 [Posted by: Gavric  | Date: 09/28/08 08:50:03 AM]
Reply

7. 
Hi, could you please test the HD video decode with a better codec, like CoreAVC; http://www.coreavc.com/
It uses less resources so maybe it would be able to help the Atom systems decode even FullHD material?

Also ATI has it's 2400 card available in PCI format, that offers HD video offload if used with supported applications, Cyberlinks H.264 codec for ATI cards; http://docs.cyberlink.com...264_decoder/enu/index.jsp

EDIT; and on second thought you would need an add in card to do proper HD playback, since it does not support HDCP protection by default... (VGA only)
0 0 [Posted by: Per Hansson  | Date: 09/28/08 12:08:09 PM]
Reply

8. 
Which power supply you are using? My MSI Wind PC barebone based Atom system idled at 20W with a 3.5" HDD. Without it (OS installed on CF card as MB has a CF slot), it consumes only 18W!

Considering the PSU efficency, I would say Atom syste consumes about 15W at idle. It does not make sense to feed a 15W system with a 500W+ PSU which would eats 40W by itself.

Just FYI, my PSU is 65W rated.
0 0 [Posted by: Roy2001  | Date: 09/28/08 10:23:27 PM]
Reply
- collapse thread

 
Please read the author's answer to my post (2nd one) above
0 0 [Posted by: Bingle  | Date: 09/29/08 01:40:58 AM]
Reply
 
Thanks for pointing that out. A 620W PSU for a 15W-30W system? No, power consumption data won't make sense as PSU itself would eats 40W.
0 0 [Posted by: Roy2001  | Date: 10/02/08 10:58:36 AM]
Reply

9. 
Isabel roshe runs did trail blazers jersey more celine black friday for pandora Fanny babyliss than mcm handbags telling jordan her rolex watches to ralph lauren black friday cheer soccer shoes up. michael kors outlet Everything detroit pistons jerseys that christian louboutin Fanny philadelphia 76ers jersey inherited womens clothing from swarovski her dsquared2 outlet father, jimmy choo shoes old ralph lauren factory store Aleck adidas tracksuits Minafer, dolphins nfl jersey had roshe run been oakley outlet invested tommy hilfiger in prada outlet Wilbur's nhl jerseys business; and bills nfl jersey Wilbur's michael kors bags business, toms outlet after nike store a atlanta hawks jersey period mbt shoes of cheap nike shoes illness canada gooses outlet corresponding kate spade outlet in nike roshe dates burberry canada to the cleveland cavaliers jersey illness of los angeles clippers jerseys Wilbur's toms shoes outlet body, cheap ray ban had adidas died abercrombie fitch just fendi outlet before Wilbur ray ban did. michael kors George salomon Amberson coach factory outlet and Fanny prada sunglasses were the north face outlet both nike "wiped ray-ban sunglasses out ray ban to new balance outlet a rolex montre miracle replica watches of nike air precision," tory burch outlet as barbour jacket outlet Amberson abercrombie and fitch said. They coach outlet "owned cheap ray ban not tommy hilfiger outlet a longchamp outlet penny coach black friday and jets nfl jersey owed michael kors australia not oakley sungalsses outlet a roshe run penny," moncler jackets he lacoste outlet continued, nike explaining beats by dre his phrase. coach outlet "It's nike like tommy hilfiger the watches moment ralph lauren polos just ray ban sunglasses before lunette oakley drowning: kate spade outlet you're hollister not north face backpacks under coach outlet online water wedding dresses sale and miami heat jerseys you're horloges not barbour jackets out nike free of coach black friday it. coach outlet All ugg you nike free run know under armour is handbags outlet that oakley sunglasses outlet you're bengals nfl jersey not converse shoes dead true religion jeans yet." barbour jackets He burberry uk spoke cheap jerseys philosophically, air max having adidas his chiefs nfl jersey "prospects" burberry outlet from christian louboutin his burberry uk father oakley outlet online to chicago bulls jerseys fall canada gooses jackets back coach black friday upon; asics but coach outlet online Fanny had instyler neither ugg boots "prospects" air max nor toms outlet philosophy. rolex watches for sale However, nike air max a uggs black friday legal timberland outlet survey barbour jackets outlet of eyeglasses online Wilbur's burberry outlet online estate longchamp handbags outlet revealed cheap mlb jerseys the ugg boots fact basketball shoes that oakley vault his kate spade life ralph lauren outlet insurance nike free was new balance left buccaneers nfl jersey clear panthers nfl jersey of softball bats the ray ban wreck; polo ralph lauren and chrome hearts outlet Isabel, valentino with oakley vault the baseball bats cheerful michael kors usa consent of timberland boots her philipp plein son, uggs on sale promptly mlb jerseys turned burberry this new balance shoes salvage adidas shoes over designer handbags to swarovski her air max sister-in-law. giuseppe shoes Invested, suns jersey it ralph lauren outlet online would hilfiger yield hollister something cheap ugg boots better browns nfl jersey than cowboys nfl jersey nine abercrombie and fitch hundred converse dollars swarovski jewelry a oakley year, rams nfl jersey and michael kors outlet thus relojes she nfl jerseys was air max assured seahawks nfl jersey of nike becoming colts nfl jersey neither cheap oakley a hermes pauper nba jersey nor nike free run a nike air max dependent, tn pas cher but burberry outlet proved titans nfl jersey to chargers nfl jersey be, mizuno running as Amberson prada shoes said, lions nfl jersey adding polo outlet online his guess factory efforts burberry outlet to nike store the occhiali ray ban cheering up 49ers nfl jersey of nike roshe run Fanny, oakley sungalsses outlet "an bcbg dresses heiress, jaguars nfl jersey after thomas sabo all, oklahoma city thunder jerseys in nike roshe spite houston rockets jersey of pandora jewelry rolling ray ban mills nike mercurial and versace outlet the devil." denver nuggets jersey She mont blanc pens was jordan release dates unable to cheap nfl jerseys smile, timberland and coach factory outlet online he kings jersey continued patriots nfl jersey his nike air max humane coach outlet usa gayeties. ralph lauren "See nike shoes outlet what ugg australia a uggs boots wonderfully coach factory outlet desirable ed hardy income pandora nine michael kors outlet hundred thomas sabo dollars nfl jerseys is, handbags outlet Fanny: spurs jersey a broncos nfl jersey bachelor, hugo boss online to ralph lauren be toms shoes in falcons nfl jersey your ray ban sunglasses outlet class, ferragamo must have longchamp handbags exactly five finger shoes forty-nine thousand replica handbags one ray ban hundred ray ban outlet a orlando magic jersey year. nike factory Then, insanity workout you warriors jersey see, michael kors handbags all burberry handbags outlet you hilfiger outlet need ray ban black friday to tory burch sandals do, burberry outlet online in christian louboutin shoes order michael kors black friday to scarpe hogan have hollister fifty thousand nike air a ray ban wayfarer year, nike huarache is nike free 5.0 to burberry outlet be vans a ravens nfl jersey little encouraging hair straightener when ralph lauren online shop some michael kors outlet bachelor michael kors outlet online in cheap jerseys your class eagles nfl jersey begins beats by dre headphones to nike show northface by hollisterco his oakley sunglasses cheap haberdashery azcardinals nfl jersey what cheap shoes he hollister clothing store wants saints nfl jersey you longchamp to michael kors outlet think oakley sunglasses outlet about north face jackets him!" toms outlet She giuseppe zanotti looked cheap true religion at him ugg boots clearance wanly, the north face jackets murmured calvin klein a puma shoes desolate burberry response—she north face outlet had abercrombie "sewing swarovski to oakley sunglasses do"—and air huarache left ray ban the swarovski canada room; adidas while prada Amberson bucks jersey shook ugg australia his omega watches head adidas ruefully at uggs outlet his oakley sunglasses outlet sister. ralph lauren "I've ugg often thought uggs that ray ban sunglasses humor rolex watches was michael kors outlet online not uggs my michael kors forte," michael kors he sighed. charlotte hornets jersey "Lord! grizzlies jersey She doesn't coach outlet 'cheer mcm backpack up' mcm handbags much!" ralph lauren The michael kors outlet online sale collegian polo ralph lauren outlet online did prada handbags not north face return boston celtics jerseys to pandora jewellery his swarovski crystal home steelers nfl jersey for juicy couture the new balance holidays. packers nfl jersey Instead, true religion outlet store Isabel cheap jordans joined raptors jersey him, toms shoes and the north face they pandora charms went adidas South true religion for beats headphones the abercrombie and fitch two timberwolves jersey weeks. She michael kors handbags was bottega proud of vans her vans shoes stalwart, hilfiger online shop good-looking chi flat iron son at polo ralph lauren the ferragamo shoes hotel ray ban where michael kors outlet online they coach black friday stayed, mk outlet online and jordan shoes it bcbg max was true religion jeans outlet meat hermes outlet and adidas shoes drink jordan retro to juicy couture outlet her michael kors when true religion outlet she ralph lauren saw supra shoes how people cheap jerseys stared katespade at nike him long champ in levi's jeans the coach outlet lobby oakley sungalsses outlet and ralph lauren uk on air max 90 the beats by dr dre big tommy hilfiger verandas—indeed, her polo ralph lauren outlet vanity burberry handbags in ray bans him hermes birkin was the north face so dominant omega watches that uhren she was unaware iphone case of michael kors uk their ralph lauren outlet staring at polo outlet her new york knicks jerseys with texans nfl jersey more michael kors interest longchamp black friday and los angeles lakers jerseys an redskins nfl jersey admiration hogan friendlier pandora uk than George oakley sungalsses outlet evoked. christian louboutin outlet Happy jimmy choo to abercrombie kids have p90x workout him adidas schuhe to michael kors outlet herself reebok for mcm bags this cheap michael kors fortnight, bottega veneta she christian louboutin shoes loved cheap nhl jerseys to moncler outlet walk michael kors outlet with oakley black friday him, toms shoes leaning coach purses outlet upon ray ban sunglasses outlet his air max arm, vikings nfl jersey to mcm backpack outlet read burberry with toms.com him, nba shoes to new balance watch michael kors black friday the oakley sungalsses outlet sea nets jerseys with north face him—perhaps uggs on sale most of uggs outlet all michael kors outlet online she oakley sunglasses outlet liked polo ralph to retro jordans enter air max 2015 the raiders nfl jersey big salvatore ferragamo dining givenchy antigona room longchamp outlet with marc jacobs him. cheap oakley sunglasses Yet michaelkors.com both rolex watches of longchamp them woolrich outlet felt tory burch sale constantly nike canada the bears nfl jersey difference soccer shoes outlet between nike air max this air force Christmastime adidas yeezy shoes and hollister clothing other Christmas-times wizards jersey of eyeglass frames theirs—in air jordans all, timberland shoes it jazz jersey was giants nfl jersey a ray ban sorrowful dallas mavericks jersey holiday. flat iron But nike shoes outlet when louboutin Isabel tory burch outlet came marc jacobs East pacers jersey for pelicans jersey George's air max 2015 commencement, in June, huarache she brought converse Lucy armani exchange with ugg her—and asics outlet things red bottoms began to barbour seem michael kors different, celine handbags especially puma when converse sneakers George

iphone cases
0 0 [Posted by: cpp  | Date: 01/04/17 10:27:51 AM]
Reply

[1-9]

Back to the Article

Add your Comment