Information

Dear forum members,
We are delighted to inform you that our forums are back online. Every single topic and post are now on their places and everything works just as before, only better. Welcome back!



Discussion

Discussion on Article:
Nvidia Quadro FX vs. ATI FirePro: Professional Graphics Accelerators Roundup

Started by: TAViX | Date 07/21/09 09:59:01 PM
Comments: 100 | Last Comment:  09/25/16 04:49:25 AM

Expand all threads | Collapse all threads

[1-7]

1. 
Superb test. I was waiting for something like this for years. Any chance we can have a test of some Tesla boards from nVidia? Thank you.
0 0 [Posted by: TAViX  | Date: 07/21/09 09:59:01 PM]
Reply

2. 
With professional apps relying rather loosely on hardware shaders, its funny to see how little separates the best from the worst performers here. In the gaming world, something similar to the FX4800 would eat the FX580 for breakfast - I guess at 1920x1200 the difference would be something like 1000% in favor of the FX4800 - and now those two cards are generally only 30-40% apart performance-wise! This leads me to think that the FX580 represents some insane value for the performance it offers. Very interesting to read!
0 0 [Posted by: npp  | Date: 07/22/09 10:54:34 AM]
Reply

3. 
Why do I find this review so hard to accept as unbiased?

I hate to question the integrity of the writer, but sure doesn't match what I have read on other sites. Nvidia Quadros do well with some cards in some apps, and AMD FirePro do well in others.

Has anyone checked out any reports from people who actually use the application software for a living ( e.g. http://robrodriguez.com/wordpress/?p=699).


By the way, since when is 10-bit support considered peculiar?
0 0 [Posted by: pandemonium  | Date: 07/22/09 02:31:54 PM]
Reply

4. 
Great review !! Finally a decent overview on how these cards perform with the latest applications instead using these old SPECs over again.

I´d hugely appreciate it if Xbitlabs could compare these results with maybe six consumer cards with the exact same testbed.

I think a lot of people consider working with consumer cards, cost-wise or just wanting to use it for both worlds, work and gaming.
More and more realtime hardware shading with DirectX9 (for example Max2009+) becomes important when working on a scene and I´m not the only one asking himself why for instance a nvidia GTX285 with obviously more horsepower should perform worse than a QuadroFX3800 just because of the drivers. It doesn´t make sense, over the long run and both AMD and nvidia have got to understand it.

Maybe a truthful investigation and comparison from a respected hardware site shall make an impact...
0 0 [Posted by: mhaZe  | Date: 07/23/09 05:26:18 AM]
Reply

5. 
Great review!!

I would also like to see a comparison with consumer cards: it seems like the recent versions of some pro apps (like Maya) don't see such a big difference between a radeon and a firepro
0 0 [Posted by: NormanBates  | Date: 08/03/09 12:43:14 AM]
Reply

6. 
I completely agree with pandemonium! I have been researching what will be the next pro graphics cards in my new workstations, and all the other benchmarks on other sites all give similar results to each other except this review! On other sites ATI’s v8700 and older v7700 sit at the top of the charts in many of the tests, putting most of Nvidia’s newest Quadro cards to shame, although the fx4800 is a top contender in most tests. I am not biased toward ATI or Nvidia and I will buy whatever is the best hardware within my price range, but this review is clearly biased toward Nvidia, putting the v8700 on par with Nvidia’s low-end solutions! Complete BS! The writer of this review is clearly an Nvidia fanboy or taking some serious backhanders from Nvidia or its partners! I noticed at the bottom of this page it states ATI as being one of this sites sponsors. I wonder what AMD/ATI would think about these benchmark results and why they are sponsoring this BS?
0 0 [Posted by: DoDidDont  | Date: 08/09/09 10:39:01 AM]
Reply
- collapse thread

 
There's a reason more than 70% of real world professionals use Nvidia Quadro FX. It's just business!
0 0 [Posted by: beck2448  | Date: 08/12/09 11:16:30 PM]
Reply

7. 
Soccer Boots Outlet nike
Toms Shoes For Women
fendi pas cher
Air Jordan Release Date
newest lebron shoes
toms shoes outlet
Ray ban sale online
new balance sportschuhe
outlet prada online
longchamp kaufen
abercrombie and fitch store
scarpe running new balance
adidas site officiel
sac givenchy
Air Jordan News
cheap christian louboutin
prada outlet
nike free
vans shoe store
polo ralph lauren pas cher
air max pas cher femme
chaussure basket homme
converse store
huarache sneakers
goedkope nike air max
moncler girls
sandalias birkenstock
sac a main michael kors
chaussure Nike homme
Chaussure Nike Pas Cher
balenciaga borse
scarpe nike
Ugg boots Sale
fitflop online kopen
pandora bracelet charms
moncler coats for women
ray ban sale
nike skor outlet
Nike Zapatos
womens nike air max
ugg boots for women
christian louboutin outlet
nike sb stefan janoski
ugg factory outlet
nike jordan shoes
Korting sportschoenen
michael kors handbags on sale
new balance sito ufficiale
Nike Online Store
outlet zapatos online
scarpe hogan outlet
charms pandora pas cher
louboutin heels
retro jordans for cheap
zapatillas running
Moncler Sale
toms sale
ugg clearance
ray ban wayfarer eyeglasses
nike air schuhe herren
asics sko
23 is back
Moncler Outlet Online
billige nike sko
adidas schoenen
michael kors väska rea
nike sportschuhe damen
Lebron 13
nike schuhe günstig
uggs outlet
ugg boots outlet online
abercrombie deutschland
tienda online abercrombie españa
Canada Goose Outlet
pandora charm bracelet sale
botas de futbol
new jordan releases
cheap mbt shoes sale
sac coach soldes
nike tn pas cher
moncler outlet
scarpe adidas online
zapatillas nike baratas
nike shoes
cheap nike air max
official NHL jerseys
Jordan Store
Toms Outlet Online
nike mercurial soccer cleats
cheap air max outlet
ugg boots classic
Uomo Hogan
adidas outlet
scarpe nike running
pandora jewelry store
Jordan Schoenen
hyperdunk 2014
fitflops sale uk
Ray Ban Outlet
chaussure adidas pas cher
oakley sunglasses clearance
pandora beads
bambas adidas baratas
michael kors bags outlet
Billiga Nike Air Max
burberry sac pas cher
timberland outlet
adidas kläder
new balance femme
chaussure new balance femme
adidas sneakers
ropa abercrombie
coach sac à main
burberry sac pas cher
scarpe jordan
nike joggesko
coach factory outlet online
air force one pas cher
cheap uggs for women
zapatos de futbol nike
tru religion jeans
nfl store
discount ray bans
zapatilla adidas
Cheap Michael Kors
Jordan Sneakers For Sale
moncler jacket sale
ugg outlet online
chaussures nike pas cher
Coach Bags On Sale
portafoglio michael kors
mulberry väskor rea
Miu Miu bags online
adidas schuhe neu
oakley outlet
new yeezy shoes
New Balance Outlet
scarpe adidas donna
Timberland skor
Adidas schuhe
adidas outlet stores online
Air Max 90
reebok running shoes
adidas shoenen
adidas tienda online
ugg store
religion store
new pandora charms
nike chaussures
nike damenschuhe
nike sportschuhe
chaussure Nike femme
Nike Store
burberry schal
uggs for cheap
chaussures de foot pas cher
Nike Air Jordan 11
nike air max running shoes
nike sneakers
nike air
adidas store
cheap uggs
lkh 9.25
0 0 [Posted by: lkh  | Date: 09/25/16 04:49:25 AM]
Reply

[1-7]

Back to the Article

Add your Comment