Dear forum members,
We are delighted to inform you that our forums are back online. Every single topic and post are now on their places and everything works just as before, only better. Welcome back!


Discussion on Article:
Heat Column Cooler: Noiseblocker NB-TwinTec Review

Started by: AnonymousGuy | Date 05/24/11 12:56:25 PM
Comments: 5 | Last Comment:  06/11/11 01:52:02 AM

Expand all threads | Collapse all threads


A 5 year old could tell you this is a stupid design. Metal -> Metal heat transfer is excellent compared to Metal -> Air. Thus you need a helluva lot of fins for a few heatpipes and they try to boost the transfer coefficient with surface area rather than conductivity. By putting a giant slab of copper in the middle of the tower, the killed the surface area of the fins without improving the cooling. I bet you could take that "central copper" out and shrink the heatsink down by the same width and you'd get the same results.
1 0 [Posted by: AnonymousGuy  | Date: 05/24/11 12:56:25 PM]

Have you guys verified if the positioning of the cooler affects its performance? If I understand correctly, the heat column technology uses some sort of phase-change process, where liquid evaporates in the hot part (near the cpu) and condenses in the cooler parts (near the fins), capturing thermal energy near the cpu and releasing it in the fins. However, for this process to function correctly, it must rely on convective movements that should be affected by gravity (lower density gas has a tendency to go up, while higher density liquid goes down). In that sense, then, the heat column should function better when it is positioned vertically, instead of the typical horizontal position inside a tower pc. Note that the same principle is applied to heat-pipes, but these are much thinner and usually have a mesh inside, making them less reliant on convection and more on capillary mass transfer, thus less affected by their position.
1 0 [Posted by: MrKepler  | Date: 05/25/11 03:38:37 AM]
- collapse thread

It is true, but how much it is useful in from the practical point of view? You know cases (except for HTPC) in which the motherboard is horizontally much?
And such cooler simply won't get into the HTPC-case.
1 0 [Posted by: Jordan  | Date: 05/25/11 05:20:19 AM]
Err no. With a fan rushing air past the fins, convection becomes negligible.
0 0 [Posted by: AnonymousGuy  | Date: 05/26/11 11:03:09 PM]

This product sucks. =D
0 0 [Posted by: TeemuMilto  | Date: 05/25/11 10:16:57 AM]


Back to the Article

Add your Comment