Information

X-bit Labs for mobile users! Do not forget that we are running a special version of X-bit Labs web-site for users of mobile and handheld devices: http://pda.xbitlabs.com. Check out our news and articles from smartphones and PDAs to be always updated on the latest computer and technology news.

Memory

Court Overturns Federal Trade Commission’s Ruling Against Rambus.

FTC Will Have to Reconsider Evidences Against Rambus

Category: Memory

by Anton Shilov

[ 04/28/2008 | 11:52 PM ]

Rambus, a developer of memory and interface technologies, announced last week that the US Court of Appeals for the DC circuit has overturned the Federal Trade Commission's (FTC) decisions regarding Rambus, and remanded the matter back to the FTC for further proceedings consistent with the Court’s opinion.

<%BANNER[article_nw]%>

Back in 2006 the commission found that Rambus withheld information that would have been highly material to the standard-setting process within JEDEC. JEDEC expressly sought information about patents to enable its members to make informed decisions about which technologies to adopt, and JEDEC members viewed early knowledge of potential patent consequences as vital for avoiding patent hold-up. As a consequence, FTC believes, Rambus illegally obtained key patents on technologies used in today’s dynamic random access memory (DRAM) chips.

In its unanimous decision released last week, the appellate court determined the FTC failed to demonstrate that Rambus inflicted any harm on competition.

“We hold, therefore, that the Commission failed to demonstrate that Rambus’ conduct was exclusionary and thus to establish its claim that Rambus unlawfully monopolized the relevant markets,” the court is reported to have said.

In addition, regarding the chance of further proceedings on remand, the Court expressed “serious concerns about the strength of the evidence relied on to support some of the Commission’s crucial findings”.

The FTC brought anti-trust charges against Rambus in 2002. A three-month trial was held in the spring of 2003 before Chief Administrative Law Judge Stephen McGuire, who issued his initial decision exonerating Rambus with over 1600 findings of fact in its favor in early 2004. The FTC’s own Complaint Counsel appealed the decision of the fact-finder to the full Commission, which reversed the ALJ and found Rambus liable for violating Section 2 of the Sherman Act. Today’s decision vacates the orders of the full Commission.

Related news

Discussion

Comments currently: 0

Add your Comment

Name/Nickname
Your Comments
 

News Archive

Memory

April, 2008
  12
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
222324
25
26
27
28
29
30
   
 
< March, 2008 May, 2008 >
 

Latest News

Friday, July 18, 2008

8:21 pm | Multimedia Nintendo Wii on Top Again Despite of PlayStation 3 Sales Skyrocket – NPD. Market of Video Games and Consoles Continues to Grow in the USA

12:13 pm | Multimedia Sony Has No Plans to Cut PlayStation 3 Pricing – Company. Sony Aims at Profitability, Not Unit Sales with PlayStation 3, Says Chief Financial Officer

6:49 am | Other Intel Denies Accusations of Illegal Business Practices. Intel: CPU Market Is Highly Competitive, AMD’s EC’s Allegations are Unfounded

6:03 am | Storage Micron and Seagate to Lead Solid State Drive Standardization Efforts at JEDEC. JEDEC Announces Dedicated Subcommittee to Set Standards for SSDs

Thursday, July 17, 2008

11:12 pm | Other European Commission Accuses Intel of More Elements of Anti-Competitive Behaviour. European Commission Finds More Examples of Intel’s Illegal Business Practices

8:00 pm | Memory Samsung and Sun Claim that Newly Developed Flash Memory for Servers Will Live Longer than Data Processing Servers. Samsung and Sun Develop Ultra Durable Memory for Server Solid State Drives

2:36 pm | CPU AMD’s Chief Executive Officer Hector Ruiz Steps Down. Dirk Meyer Becomes New Chief Exec of AMD

12:15 pm | CPU Intel: Atom Will Not Substitute Celeron Processors. Intel Denies Possibility to Change Celeron for Atom

10:07 am | Multimedia Sony Cuts Price on PlayStation 3, Axes Backwards Compatibility Too. Sony PlayStation 3 80GB to Cost $399, Backwards Compatibility Lost

5:48 am | Video Microsoft Preps to Unveil DirectX 11 Features in Several Days. ATI, Nvidia, Microsoft to Discuss DirectX 11 Techniques at XNA, Siggraph

 
News Archive