Bookmark and Share


Microsoft Corp. has again condemned stereoscopic 3D technology as it exists today and called it a science experiment rather than a new product category with a significant market potential. The worst thing about the current stereo-3D (S3D) is necessity to wear special glasses that enable the effect.

"[Batman: Arkham Asylum with S3D support for Xbox 360] felt a little more like a science experiment than something that's going to go touch millions of people. Clearly, we're not going to ignore 3-D. I think it is something that will play a role in entertainment," said Phil Spencer, the corporate vice president for Microsoft Game Studios, in an interview with CNN.

It is hardly the first time when Microsoft criticizes S3D in its current form. It is obvious that it is uncomfortable to say at least for multiply people to play in stereo-3D games on one screen simultaneously. Moreover, S3D costs a lot of money to end-users: a new HDTV as well as stereo-3D glasses that may cost over $100 a pair. Finally, even Sony Computer Entertainment had to decrease resolution of S3D games compared to normal PlayStation 3 games in order to sustain performance.

"As an entertainment company, we are trying to do things that millions of people can go enjoy today. And for better or for worse, people just don't really have TVs in their house right now that are going to do 3D in a way that's going to work. [...] As a corporate mandate, I don't need to sell you a new TV. [...] A bunch of people sitting around the living room wearing $150 glasses - I am just not sure that's kind of mainstream today. Trying to get a bunch of people playing together in a room where not everybody sees the same thing [...] is kind of a weird disconnect to me," said Mr. Spencer.

Even though stereo-3D-supporting games for Xbox 360 will be released by various developers, it looks like Microsoft itself does not want to promote the technology just now. Perhaps, since the company now has to promote its Kinect motion sensor controller and putting resources into two technologies is just inefficient.

Tags: Microsoft, Xbox, Stereo 3D, Playstation, Sony


Comments currently: 6
Discussion started: 10/21/10 01:07:45 PM
Latest comment: 10/24/10 07:06:12 AM
Expand all threads | Collapse all threads


Way to deliberately miss the point of what they said.

"[a particular game] felt more like a science experiment... Clearly, we're not going to ignore 3-D"

is translated as

"Stereo-3D Today Is a Science Experiment - Microsoft: Microsoft Condemns S3D Again"

0 0 [Posted by: bluvg  | Date: 10/21/10 01:07:45 PM]
- collapse thread

"[a particular game] felt more like a science experiment..."
was about Stereo 3-D.
"Clearly, we're not going to ignore 3-D"
was about 3-D in general.

No contradiction here.
0 0 [Posted by: KonradK  | Date: 10/22/10 04:34:03 AM]
What 3-D is not "stereo"???
0 0 [Posted by: bluvg  | Date: 10/22/10 04:11:32 PM]
Holographic 3-D. It is even produced now
Also autostereoscopic 3-D that reportedly will be used by Nintendo 3DS, although still belongs to the "stereo 3-D family" does not require special glasses (that is main concern in case non-autostereoscopic 3-D).
0 0 [Posted by: KonradK  | Date: 10/22/10 11:17:08 PM]
Clearly, they are not talking about holographic 3D.

Even then, on some level, 3D implies stereo. Without two "channels" (eyes, cameras, or whatever), you don't have 3D.
0 0 [Posted by: bluvg  | Date: 10/23/10 11:23:02 PM]
Right. Stereo (without quotation marks) is unavoidable (even quadro contains stereo). After all limitations of the human anatomy cannot be overcome. I think they were talking about "stereo" in very narrow sense i.e. about (non-auto)stereoscopic 3-D. "The worst thing about the current stereo-3D (S3D) is necessity to wear special glasses that enable the effect." statement was context.
0 0 [Posted by: KonradK  | Date: 10/24/10 07:06:12 AM]


Add your Comment

Related news

Latest News

Monday, April 14, 2014

8:23 am | Microsoft Vows to Release Xbox 360 Emulator for Xbox One. Microsoft Xbox One May Gain Compatibility with Xbox 360 Games

Tuesday, April 1, 2014

10:39 am | Microsoft Reveals Kinect for Windows v2 Hardware. Launch of New Kinect for Windows Approaches

Tuesday, March 25, 2014

1:57 pm | Facebook to Acquire Virtual Reality Pioneer, Oculus VR. Facebook Considers Virtual Reality as Next-Gen Social Platform

1:35 pm | Intel Acquires Maker of Wearable Computing Devices. Basis Science Becomes Fully-Owned Subsidiary of Intel

Monday, March 24, 2014

10:53 pm | Global UHD TV Shipments Total 1.6 Million Units in 2013 – Analysts. China Ahead of the Whole World with 4K TV Adoption

10:40 pm | Crytek to Adopt AMD Mantle Mantle API for CryEngine. Leading Game Developer Adopts AMD Mantle

9:08 pm | Microsoft Unleashes DirectX 12: One API for PCs, Mobile Gadgets and Xbox One. Microsoft Promises Increased Performance, New Features with DirectX 12

3:33 pm | PowerVR Wizard: Imagination Reveals World’s First Ray-Tracing GPU IP for Mobile Devices. Imagination Technologies Brings Ray-Tracing, Hybrid Rendering Modes to Smartphones and Tablets

2:00 pm | Nokia Now Expects to Close Deal with Microsoft in Q2. Sale of Nokia’s Division to Close Next Month